| Brian Mathiowetz | 2420 | 2023 | Stillwater, MN | Eleva, WI |
| Tom Montsma | 2360 | 2023 | Stillwater, MN | Brandon, WI |
| Barlow / Jacobus | 2283 | 2018 | Bloomfield, IA | Gays Mills, WI |
| Mike Schmit | 2261 | 2019 | Stillwater Harvest Festival | Markesan, WI |
| Jacobus Family | 2210 | 2022 | Stillwater Harvestfest | Soldiers Grove, WI |
| Josiah Brandt | 2185 | 2015 | Stillwater, MN | Rudolph, WI |
| Jim Ford | 2177 | 2023 | All Community Events Pumpkin Weigh-off US National Championship | Eldorado, WI |
| Deb Gantner | 2152 | 2018 | Nekoosa, WI | Oshkosh, WI |
| John and Merri Barlow | 2151.5 | 2023 | Ryan Norlin Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Gays Mills, WI |
| Derek Sippel | 2147.5 | 2022 | Mishicot Pumpkin Festival | St. Cloud, WI |