| Chris Kent | 350.5 | 2013 | Operation Pumpkin | Sevierville, TN |
| Andrew Vial | 341.5 | 2019 | Tennessee Valley Fair | Liberty, NC |
| Frank Mudd | 341 | 2019 | Roberts Family Farms | Vine Grove, KY |
| Frank Mudd | 333.5 | 2019 | Tennessee Valley Fair | Vine Grove, KY |
| Frank Mudd | 332 | 2017 | Roberts Family Farms | Vine Grove, KY |
| Andrew Vial | 330.5 | 2019 | North Carolina State Fair | Liberty, NC |
| Andrew Vial | 329 | 2021 | Spring Hope National Pumpkin Festival | Liberty, NC |
| Chris Kent | 327.5 | 2018 | North Carolina State Fair | Sevierville, TN |
| Gabriele Bartoli | 326 | 2012 | Festa Della zucca di sale | Novellara RE, Italy |
| Frank Mudd | 325.4 | 2022 | Allardt Pumpkin Festival | Vine Grove, KY |