| Ralph Laub | 2289 | 2024 | The Center Street Giant Pumpkin Festival | Vernal, UT |
| Mohamed Sadiq | 2287 | 2022 | The Nut Tree World Championship Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Bountiful, UT |
| Ross Bowman | 2142 | 2021 | Hee Haw Farms | Brigham City, UT |
| Matt McConkie | 1974 | 2017 | Thanksgiving Point | Mountain Green, UT |
| Mohamed Sadiq | 1905 | 2022 | Hee Haw Farms | Bountiful, UT |
| Alan Gebert | 1872 | 2024 | The Center Street Giant Pumpkin Festival | Millville, UT |
| Ralph Laub | 1838 | 2024 | Gateway Giant Pumpkinpalooza | Vernal, UT |
| Mohamed Sadiq | 1825 | 2020 | Thanksgiving Point | Bountiful, UT |
| Matt McConkie | 1817 | 2014 | Uesugi Farms, CA | Mountain Green, UT |
| Andrew Israelsen | 1782 | 2024 | The Center Street Giant Pumpkin Festival | Salt Lake City, UT |