| Joe Jutras | 2118 | 2017 | Frerichs Farm Weigh-off | North Scituate, RI |
| Joe Jutras | 1935 | 2019 | Topsfield | North Scituate, RI |
| Scott Holub | 1844.5 | 2016 | Baumans Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Eugene, OR |
| Joe Jutras | 1838 | 2020 | Frerichs Farm Weigh-off | North Scituate, RI |
| Scott Holub | 1807.5 | 2017 | Baumans Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Eugene, OR |
| Mario Weishaeupl | 1717.4 | 2020 | Tharinger Meisterschaft | Waldkirchen, Bavaria |
| Joe Jutras | 1701 | 2017 | Durham Fair | North Scituate, RI |
| Lee & Derrik Zappa | 1652.5 | 2020 | PGPGA Great Pumpkin Weigh-off | Mercer, PA |
| John Sikorski | 1628 | 2020 | Green Bay Fall Festival | Suring, WI |
| Scott Holub | 1578 | 2014 | Baumans Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Eugene, OR |