| Joe Jutras | 2200 | 2025 | Frerichs Farms SNGPG | North Scituate, OR |
| Todd & Donna Skinnger | 2164 | 2021 | Oakland Nursery Weigh-Off | Barnesville, OH |
| Joe Jutras | 2118 | 2017 | Frerichs Farm Weigh-off | North Scituate, RI |
| Cindy Tobeck | 2030 | 2021 | Baumans Farm Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Olympia, WA |
| Cindy Tobek | 1997 | 2022 | The Nut Tree World Championship Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Olympia, WA |
| Joe Jutras | 1944 | 2022 | SNGPG Frerichs Farm Weigh-off | North Scituate, OH |
| Joe Jutras | 1935 | 2019 | Topsfield | North Scituate, RI |
| Quin Werner | 1896.5 | 2025 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers | Saegertown, PA |
| Nic Welty | 1893.5 | 2022 | Dundees Pumpkin Palooza | Suttons Bay, MI |
| Cindy Tobek | 1884 | 2023 | Baumans Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Olympia, OR |