| Kevin Marsh | 2006 | 2024 | Riverview Christmas Tree Farm Pumpkin festival | Parker, SD |
| Kevin Marsh | 1837.5 | 2024 | Great Downtown Pumpkin Festival | Parker, SD |
| Greg Kurkowski | 1823 | 2021 | Riverview Christmas Tree Farm Pumpkin festival | Watertown, SD |
| Ryan Althoff | 1797 | 2023 | Stillwater, MN | Watertown, SD |
| Ryan Althoff | 1695 | 2024 | Stillwater Harvestfest | Watertown, SD |
| Kevin Marsh | 1674 | 2010 | South Shore | Parker, SD |
| Kevin Marsh | 1657 | 2011 | Stillwater, MN | Parker, SD |
| Ryan Althoff | 1602 | 2023 | Riverview Christmas Tree Farm Pumpkin festival | Watertown, SD |
| Kevin Marsh | 1569 | 2015 | Rapid City, SD | Parker, SD |
| Ryan Althoff | 1553 | 2004 | Riverview Christmas Tree Farm Pumpkin Festival | Watertown, SD |