| Scott Andrusz | 2554 | 2022 | The Great Pumpkin Farm World Pumpkin Weigh-off | Williamsville, NY |
| Karl & Beverly Haist | 2517 | 2019 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers weigh-off | Clarence Center, NY |
| Andy Wolf | 2493 | 2022 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers Weigh-off | Little Valley, NY |
| Karl Haist | 2416.5 | 2018 | Canfield, OH | Clarence Center, NY |
| Andy Wolf | 2365 | 2021 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers | Little Valley, NY |
| Scott Andrusz | 2342.5 | 2024 | World Pumpkin Weigh-off | Williamsville, NY |
| Karl Haist | 2269 | 2019 | Clarence, OH | Clarence Center, NY |
| Scott Andrusz | 2251 | 2023 | Operation Pumpkin | Williamsville, NY |
| Scott Andrusz | 2245.5 | 2023 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers Weigh-off | Williamsville, NY |
| Andy & Amelia Wolf | 2225.5 | 2024 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers Weigh-off | Little Valley, NY |