| Christopher Shortway | 1673 | 2022 | Ridgefield Weigh-off | Mine Hill, NJ |
| Matthew Metta | 1635 | 2022 | Woodstock Fair | Farmingdale, NJ |
| Radcliffe & Jamieson | 1415.5 | 2015 | Monster Pumpkin Madness fair | Warren, NJ |
| Christopher Shortway | 1412 | 2023 | Ridgefield Weigh-off | Mine Hill, NJ |
| Matthew Metta | 1344.5 | 2022 | Durham Fair Weigh-off | Long Valley, NJ |
| Matthew Metta | 1341 | 2020 | Durham Fair Weigh-off | Farmingdale, NJ |
| Mike Starr | 1286 | 2017 | Grim's Orchard - Breinigsville | Long Valley, NJ |
| Christopher Shortway | 1221 | 2021 | Durham Fair Weigh-off | Mine Hill, NJ |
| Mike Starr | 1089.5 | 2019 | PGPGA Great Pumpkin Weigh-Off | Long Valley, NJ |
| Mike Starr | 971.5 | 2015 | Monster Pumpkin Madness | Long Valley, NJ |