| Brent Cernik | 1492.5 | 2019 | Ryan Norlin Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Wahoo |
| Darren Christensen | 1399 | 2014 | Ryan Norlin Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Bellevue |
| Beth Wood | 1365 | 2020 | Bloomfield Giant Pumpkin Bash | Doniphan |
| Larry & Tamra Ziems | 1275 | 2021 | Great Downtown Pumpkin Festival | Ewing |
| Beth Wood | 1166.5 | 2021 | Bloomfield Giant Pumpkin Bash | Doniphan |
| Dustin Grubbs | 998 | 2022 | Fort Collins Nursery Weigh-off | Scottsbluff |
| Larry & Tamra Ziems | 996 | 2019 | Great Downtown Pumpkin Festival | Ewing |
| Larry & Tamra Ziems | 990 | 2024 | Riverview Christmas Tree Farm Pumpkin Festival | Ewing |
| Dustin Grubbs | 981 | 2016 | Great Downtown Pumpkin Festival | Scottsbluff |
| Darren Christensen | 829 | 2014 | Harvest Bash | Bellevue |