| Richard Bottorf | 1798 | 2019 | Republic Pumpkin Daze Fall Festival | Republic |
| Richard Bottorf | 1722 | 2021 | Bloomfield | Republic |
| Richard Bottorf | 1677 | 2021 | Oklahoma Giant Pumpkin | Republic |
| Richard Bottorf | 1563 | 2017 | Republic Pumpkin Daze Fall Festival | Republic |
| Richard Bottorf | 1508 | 2021 | Republic Pumpkin Daze Fall Festival | Republic |
| Steve Kueny | 1496.6 | 2024 | Republic Pumpkin Daze Fall Festival | Lebanon |
| Richard Bottorf | 1468 | 2024 | Bloomfield Giant Pumpkin Bash | Republic |
| Shr-Lyn Cline | 1464 | 2022 | Republic Pumpkin Daze Fall Festival | Carthage |
| Shr-Lyn Cline | 1361.8 | 2023 | Republic Pumpkin Daze Fall Festival | Carthage |
| Richard Bottorf | 1304.2 | 2024 | Republic Pumpkin Daze Fall Festival | Republic |