| Al Eaton | 173.75 | 2022 | Bracebridge Agriculture Society Fall Fair | Richmond, ON | Canada |
| Sharon Eaton | 168.25 | 2022 | Bracebridge Agriculture Society Fall Fair | Richmond, ON | Canada |
| Joe Jutras | 159.00 | 2023 | Duram Fair Weigh-off | North Scituate, RI | USA |
| Goran Lazic | 155.70 | 2019 | Slovenian Weigh-off | Slovenia | Slovenia |
| Frank Ansems | 154.75 | 2021 | The Great Howard Dill Giant Pumpkin Classic | Nova Scotia | Canada |
| Jason Gfeller | 154.06 | 2022 | Michigan State Fair Weigh-off | Toledo, OH | USA |
| Frank Ansems | 153.00 | 2019 | Windsor West Hants | North Alton, NS | Canada |
| Barry LeBlanc | 152.63 | 2022 | Deerfield Fair | Merrimack, NH | USA |
| Jay Yohe | 152.25 | 2021 | PGPGA Great Pumpkin Weigh-off | Export, PA | USA |
| Elroy Morgan | 150.88 | 2023 | Damariscotta Pumpkinfest and Regatta Weigh-off | Charleston, MA | USA |