| Al Eaton | 173.75 | 2022 | Bracebridge Agriculture Society Fall Fair | Richmond, ON | Canada |
| Sharon Eaton | 168.25 | 2022 | Bracebridge Agriculture Society Fall Fair | Richmond, ON | Canada |
| Art Johnston | 165.00 | 2024 | Port Elgin Pumpkinfest Saturday | St. Thomas ON | Canada |
| Dennis Hartung | 162.5 | 2025 | Port Elgin Pumpkinfest Saturday | Palmerston, ON | Canada |
| Dennis Hartung | 160.00 | 2025 | Port Elgin Pumpkinfest Sunday | Palmerston, ON | Canada |
| Del & Julie Faust | 159.25 | 2024 | Cedarburg Wine and Harvest Festival | Fond Du Lac, WI | USA |
| Joe Jutras | 159.00 | 2023 | Duram Fair Weigh-off | North Scituate, RI | USA |
| Dennis Hartung | 158.25 | 2025 | Woodbridge Giant Pumpkin and Vegetable Competition | Palmerston, ON | Canada |
| Goran Lazic | 155.70 | 2019 | Slovenian Weigh-off | Slovenia | Slovenia |
| Frank Ansems | 154.75 | 2021 | The Great Howard Dill Giant Pumpkin Classic | Nova Scotia | Canada |