| John MacKinnon | 211 | 2014 | Windsor-West Hants Pumpkin Festival | Strathlorne, Nova Scotia |
| Quin Werner | 209 | 2012 | Canfield, OH | Saegertown, PA |
| Bradley Wursten | 205 | 2019 | Dutch Giant Vegetable Championship | Hasselt, Overijssel, The Netherlands |
| Alan Nesbitt | 204.5 | 2021 | Vermont Growers Weigh-off | Conesus, NY |
| Scott Steil | 197.5 | 2014 | Stillwater Harvestfest, MN | Richmond, Minnesota |
| John MacKinnon | 197 | 2014 | AVGVG Glad Gardens Waterville, NS | Strathlorne, Nova Scotia |
| John Kapelari | 191 | 2019 | Great White North Pumpkin weigh-off | Athabasca, Alberta, Canada |
| Mark Baggs | 190.6 | 2021 | Royal Victoria Country Park | Dorset, England |
| Scott Steil | 189.5 | 2014 | Ryan Norlin Giant Pumpkin Weighoff | Richmond, MN |
| Donald Crews | 189 | 2016 | Great White North Pumpkin Fair | Lloydminster, Alberta |