| Brad Bledsoe | 2083 | 2024 | Nicks Garden Center Weigh-off | Fort Collins, CO |
| Chad New | 1976.5 | 2024 | Jareds Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off and Frestival | Parker, CO |
| Brad Bledsoe | 1955 | 2024 | Irvine Park Railroad Great Pumpkin Weigh-off | Fort Collins, CO |
| Chad New | 1783 | 2022 | Nick's Garden Center | Parker, CO |
| Brad Bledsoe | 1729.6 | 2022 | Fort Collins Nursery Weigh-off | Fort Collins, CO |
| Joe Scherber | 1685.5 | 2016 | Jared's Weigh-off | Wheat Ridge, CO |
| Chad New | 1676 | 2021 | Fort Collins Nursery Weigh-off | Parker, CO |
| Chad New | 1676 | 2021 | Nick's Garden Center | Parker, CO |
| Chad New | 1643 | 2022 | Smith Farms Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Parker, CO |
| Joe Scherber | 1634 | 2022 | Jared's Weigh-off | Wheat Ridge, CO |