| Steve Connolly | 470.5 | 2020 | Frerichs Farm Weigh-off | Sharon, MA |
| Quinn Werner | 450.5 | 2024 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers Weigh-off | Saegertown, PA |
| Tom Trombley | 414 | 2024 | Dundees Pumpkin Palooza | Standish, MI |
| Jeremy Terry | 384.5 | 2018 | Allardt Pumpkin Festival | Helenwood, TN |
| Quinn Werner | 372.5 | 2025 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers | Saegertwon, PA |
| Doug English | 370.5 | 2022 | Ryan Norlin Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Webster Groves, MO |
| Barlow/Jacobus | 370 | 2018 | Kenosha Fall Festival | Gay Mills, WI |
| Kevin Marsh | 369 | 2019 | Great Downtown Pumpkin Festival | Parker, South Dakota |
| Debbie Gantner | 365 | 2025 | Wisconsin Great Pumpkin Weigh-off | Oshkosh, WI |
| Don Barron | 363 | 2020 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers Weigh-off | LaSalle, MI |