| Albert Rodebaugh | 2244.5 | 2025 | North Carolina State Fair | Craigsville, WV |
| Chris Rodebaugh | 2206.1 | 2024 | North Carolina State Fair | Lewisburg, WV |
| Terry & Lois Nelson | 2197.8 | 2024 | North Carolina State Fair | Thomas, WV |
| Robert Cyrus | 2194.4 | 2021 | Allardt Pumpkin Festival | Fort Gay, WV |
| Chris Rodebaugh | 2144.5 | 2023 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers Weigh-off | Lewisburg, WV |
| Robert Cyrus | 2131 | 2023 | Wild and Wonderful | Fort Gay, WV |
| Robert Cyrus | 2124 | 2023 | North Carolina State Fair | Fort Gay, WV |
| Terry & Lois Nelson | 2114.5 | 2025 | North Carolina State Fair | Thomas, WV |
| Chris Rodebaugh | 2025.7 | 2023 | North Carolina State Fair | Lewisburg, WV |
| Robert Cyrus | 1977 | 2023 | Yadkin Valley Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Fort Gay, WV |