| Robert Burchette | 1514 | 2019 | Tennessee Valley Fair | Lexington, NC |
| Elijah Meck | 1458.5 | 2017 | North Carolina State Fair | Randleman, NC |
| Danny Vester | 1404.5 | 2014 | Yadkin Valley Pumpkin Festival | Spring Hope, NC |
| Danny Vester | 1390 | 2021 | Tennessee Valley Fair | Spring Hope, NC |
| Danny Vester | 1296 | 2014 | Cullman, AL | Spring Hope, NC |
| Rick Holder | 1258 | 2009 | Yadkin Valley Pumpkin Festival | Winston Salem, NC |
| Robert Burchette | 1245 | 2020 | Spring Hope National Pumpkin Festival Weigh-off | Lexington, NC |
| Danny Vestor | 1237 | 2017 | Yadkin Valley Pumpkin Festival | Spring Hope, NC |
| Sam Lovelace | 1178.9 | 2007 | Yadkin Valley Pumpkin Festival | Sparta, NC |
| Sam Lovelace | 1175.4 | 2008 | Yadkin Valley Pumpkin Festival | Sparta, NC |