| Radcliffe & Jamieson | 1415.5 | 2015 | Monster Pumpkin Madness fair | Warren, NJ |
| Mike Starr | 1286 | 2017 | Grim's Orchard - Breinigsville | Long Valley, NJ |
| Mike Starr | 971.5 | 2015 | Monster Pumpkin Madness | Long Valley, NJ |
| Kim Puig | 910.5 | 2010 | Durham Fair | LK Hapatcong |
| Mike Starr | 863 | 2014 | Doylestown, PA | Long Valley, NJ |
| Mike Starr | 755 | 2016 | Doylestown, PA | Long Valley, NJ |
| Andrew Wetzel | 736 | 2014 | Doylestown, PA | Millville, NJ |
| Radcliffe & Jamieson | 662.5 | 2015 | Monster Pumpkin Madness fair | Warren, NJ |
| Dreher & Hoden | 441 | 2005 | PGPGA | Waretown, NJ |
| John Pilley | 195 | 2018 | Ridgefield, PA | New Providence, NJ |