| Mike Cotter | 1348 | 2023 | The Great Downtown Pumpkin Festival | Fairview, MT |
| Joe Nigro | 1325 | 2023 | The Great Downtown Pumpkin Festival | Billings, MT |
| Mike Cotter | 1286 | 2024 | Great Downtown Pumpkin Festival, SD | Fairview, MT |
| Mike Cotter | 1258 | 2022 | Great Downtown Pumpkin Festival | Fairview, MT |
| Jason McGimpsey | 1200 | 2021 | Wyoming State Championship | Billings, MT |
| Jaena Cotter | 1171 | 2022 | Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Fairview, MT |
| Kyle Koschmeder | 1168 | 2013 | Ronan Harvest Festival | Shelby, MT |
| Mike Cotter | 1115 | 2019 | Great Downtown Pumpkin Festival, SD | Fairview, MT |
| Emmett May | 1030 | 2012 | Big Sky Weigh-off | Polson, MT |
| Mike Cotter | 992 | 2021 | Great Downtown Pumpkin Festival, SD | Fairview, MT |