| Earl Thompson | 2670 | 2024 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers Weigh-off | Rockford,MI |
| Don Barron | 2460 | 2025 | Operation Pumpkin, Hamilton, OH | La Salle, MI |
| Don Barron | 2404 | 2023 | Operation Pumpkin | La Salle, MI |
| Tom Trombley | 2378.5 | 2025 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers | Standish, Mi |
| Frank Morse | 2350 | 2022 | Hamilton, OH | Waterford, MI |
| Tom Trombley | 2283 | 2023 | Operation Pumpkin | Standish, MI |
| Glenn Hoornstra | 2226.5 | 2024 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers Weigh-off | Sault Ste Marie, MI |
| Dan Fleser | 2226 | 2025 | Operation Pumpkin, Hamilton, OH | Williamston, MI |
| Tom Trombley | 2201 | 2024 | Operation Pumpkin | Standish, MI |
| Don Barron | 2144 | 2022 | Oakland Nursery, OH | LaSalle, MI |