| Jamie Graham | 2480 | 2022 | New England Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Tyngsboro, MA |
| Charlie Lieber | 2276 | 2020 | Frerichs Farm, RI | Lexington, MA |
| Steve Connolly | 2240.5 | 2022 | SNGPG Frerichs Farm Weigh-off | Sharon, MA |
| Woodrow Lancaster | 2116 | 2019 | Topsfield | Topsfield, MA |
| Steve Connolly | 2075.5 | 2016 | Topsfield | Sharon, MA |
| Thomas Keenan | 2074 | 2023 | New England Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Swampscott, MA |
| Dan Kruszyna | 2045 | 2020 | Deerfield Fair | Cheshire, MA |
| Woodrow Lancaster | 2016 | 2019 | Frerichs Farm, RI | Topsfield, MA |
| Woodrow Lancaster | 2003.5 | 2017 | Topsfield | Topsfield, MA |
| Woodrow Lancaster | 1954 | 2015 | Topsfield | Topsfield, MA |