| Alex Noel | 2507 | 2025 | New England Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Abington Pomfret, CT |
| Alex Noel | 2294.5 | 2019 | Topsfield, MA | Abington Pomgret, CT |
| Alex Noel | 2234 | 2022 | New England Giant Pumpkin Weigh-off | Abington Pomfret, CT |
| Gary Vincent | 2169.5 | 2019 | Topsfield, MA | Plainfield, CT |
| Alex Noel | 2102 | 2025 | SNGPG Frerichs Farm | Abington Pomfret, CT |
| Alex Noel | 2096.5 | 2022 | SNGPG Frerichs Farm Weigh-off | Abington Pomfret, CT |
| Alex Noel | 2092 | 2021 | Topsfield, MA | Abington Pomfret, CT |
| Ryan Cleveland | 2074.5 | 2025 | Durham Fair Weigh-Off | Higganum, CT |
| Alex Noel | 2058.5 | 2019 | SNGPG Frerichs Farm | Abington Pomfret, CT |
| Ray Leonzi | 2014.5 | 2024 | Durham Fair Weigh-Off | Trumbull, CT |