| Jared Persinger | 2505 | 2025 | Operation Pumpkin, Hamilton | Washington, OH |
| Bob and Jo Liggett | 2388.5 | 2023 | Circleville, OH | Circleville, OH |
| Adam Momirov | 2273 | 2025 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers | East Canton, OH |
| Rick Kisamore | 2266 | 2023 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers Weigh-off | Atwater, OH |
| Bob & Jo Liggett | 2226 | 2024 | Circleville, OH | Circleville, OH |
| Doug Kisamore | 2195.5 | 2022 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers Weigh-off | Diamond, OH |
| Jeff Theil | 2195 | 2021 | Barnesville Pumpkin Festival | Dillonvale, OH |
| Ray Anderson | 2194 | 2024 | Circleville, OH | Circleville, OH |
| Todd Skinner | 2150 | 2017 | Barnesville Pumpkin Festival | Barnesville, OH |
| Julie Kent | 2146.5 | 2025 | Ohio Valley Giant Pumpkin Growers Weigh-off | Hartville, OH |